Sirveil vs Incogni: An Honest Comparison for 2026
Last updated: May 2026
Incogni and Sirveil both aim to remove your personal data from data brokers, but they come from very different origins and take different approaches. Incogni is backed by Surfshark (part of Nord Security), giving it deep pockets and a massive user base. Sirveil is an independent, AI-native startup built from scratch. Here is an honest look at how they compare.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | Sirveil | Incogni |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly price | $7.99/mo | ~$7.99/mo (annual) |
| Annual price | $79.99/yr (~$6.67/mo) | $95.88/yr |
| Bundle pricing | None | $4.29/mo with Surfshark VPN bundle |
| Removal approach | AI-native automated scanning | Fully automated |
| Broker coverage | AI-driven scanning (expanding) | 420+ brokers |
| Independent audit | None | Deloitte audit (August 2025) |
| Claimed removals | Not disclosed | 245M+ |
| Dark web monitoring | Yes (DeHashed V2 integration) | No |
| FOIA filing | Yes ($49.99 per letter add-on) | No |
| Mobile apps | Native Android app (iOS coming soon) | Web-based dashboard |
| Parent company | Sirveil (independent) | Surfshark / Nord Security |
| Free tier | No | No |
Pricing
On standalone pricing, Sirveil is cheaper than Incogni. Sirveil's annual plan is $79.99 per year (about $6.67 per month) against Incogni's $95.88 per year, and Sirveil's $7.99 month-to-month rate matches Incogni's annual-billing rate. Incogni's strongest price play is the bundle: combined with a Surfshark VPN subscription, its effective price drops to around $4.29 per month, making it one of the most affordable privacy bundles on the market.
Sirveil does not offer bundle pricing or a VPN. If you already want a Surfshark VPN, the Incogni bundle is the cheaper package. As a standalone data removal service, Sirveil costs less.
Sirveil also includes dark web monitoring in its base subscription, which Incogni does not offer. If you would otherwise purchase a separate dark web monitoring service, the gap widens. Sirveil additionally offers FOIA filing ($49.99 per order) for users who need to address government and institutional records, a capability Incogni lacks entirely.
Bottom line on pricing: Sirveil is cheaper as a standalone service and includes dark web monitoring; Incogni is cheaper only when bundled with a Surfshark VPN.
Broker Coverage
Incogni covers 420+ data brokers with a fully automated removal process. This is a strong number, and Incogni has been transparent about which brokers it targets.
Sirveil uses AI-native scanning rather than maintaining a fixed broker list. This approach is designed to discover where your data appears dynamically rather than relying solely on a predetermined set of brokers. The trade-off is that Sirveil's coverage is harder to quantify with a single number, whereas Incogni's 420+ gives users a concrete benchmark.
For users who want to know exactly how many brokers are being checked, Incogni's explicit count is reassuring. For users who believe the broker landscape is constantly shifting and want a system that adapts, Sirveil's AI-driven approach has theoretical advantages.
Independent Verification
This is one of Incogni's strongest differentiators. In August 2025, Incogni published results of a Deloitte audit verifying its removal processes. This is a meaningful credential. Independent third-party audits are rare in the privacy industry, and having a Big Four accounting firm validate your claims is a significant trust signal.
Incogni also claims 245 million or more successful removals. That number is large and hard to independently verify beyond the Deloitte audit, but the audit itself lends credibility to the overall operation.
Sirveil has not undergone an independent audit. This is a fair criticism, and we will not pretend otherwise. Sirveil compensates by being transparent about what it can and cannot guarantee. No removal service can promise 100% deletion of your data, and Sirveil says so openly rather than leading with inflated statistics.
For users who place a high premium on third-party verification, Incogni's Deloitte audit is a genuine advantage. For users who value straightforward honesty over credential-based trust, Sirveil's transparent positioning may resonate.
Dark Web Monitoring
Sirveil includes dark web monitoring powered by DeHashed V2 as part of its base subscription. This scans for your personal information, including email addresses, passwords, phone numbers, and other identifiers, appearing in breached databases and dark web marketplaces.
Incogni does not offer dark web monitoring. Its focus is exclusively on data broker removal. If you want dark web coverage alongside Incogni, you would need to add a separate service.
This is a meaningful differentiator for Sirveil. Data breaches and dark web exposure represent a different category of risk than data broker listings, and having both covered in a single service simplifies your privacy stack.
FOIA Filing
Sirveil offers FOIA letter filing as an add-on at $49.99 per letter. This allows users to formally request deletion of personal data from government agencies, court records, and institutional databases that are not reachable through standard data broker opt-out processes.
Incogni does not offer FOIA filing. Most data broker removal services do not, which makes this a distinctive Sirveil feature for users who need it.
This is a niche capability. Most users will never need to file a FOIA request for personal data deletion. But for those who do, particularly individuals dealing with public records, court documents, or government databases, it fills a gap that Incogni cannot address.
Mobile Experience
Sirveil was designed mobile-first with a native Android application (an iOS app is coming soon). Scan results, removal status, dark web alerts, and FOIA tracking are all accessible from a native app with push notifications and biometric authentication.
Incogni is web-based. You can access its dashboard from a mobile browser, but there is no dedicated native app. The web interface is clean and functional, but it was designed for desktop use and adapted for mobile screens rather than built for them.
For users who manage most of their digital life from their phone, Sirveil's native apps provide a more polished, responsive experience. For users who prefer desktop management, the difference is less significant.
Parent Company Considerations
Incogni is a product of Surfshark, which is itself part of Nord Security. This gives Incogni significant resources: engineering talent, infrastructure, marketing reach, and financial stability. Nord Security is one of the largest consumer privacy companies in the world.
This is mostly an advantage for Incogni. It means the service is well-funded, unlikely to disappear, and can invest heavily in automation and broker relationships.
However, some privacy-conscious users have questions about large privacy conglomerates. When one company provides your VPN, your data broker removal, and potentially other privacy tools, there is a concentration of trust. You are relying on a single entity to protect multiple dimensions of your privacy. Whether this bothers you depends on your personal threat model and trust preferences.
Sirveil is independent. It does not have Nord Security's resources, but it also does not have the potential conflicts of interest that come with being part of a large privacy conglomerate. It is a focused, single-purpose product.
Technology Approach
Incogni uses fully automated removal processes. It has built integrations with its 420+ broker partners and automates the opt-out submission process. This is efficient and scalable.
Sirveil is AI-native, meaning its core scanning and detection capabilities were built from scratch using artificial intelligence rather than traditional rule-based automation. The AI-driven approach is designed to adapt to changes in how brokers operate and to identify new data exposures that a static integration list might miss.
Both approaches have merit. Incogni's established automation is proven at scale. Sirveil's AI-native design is newer but potentially more adaptable. Neither is objectively superior; they represent different bets on how the privacy landscape will evolve.
Who Should Choose Incogni
- VPN users who can take advantage of the Surfshark bundle for exceptional value.
- Users who value independent verification and find the Deloitte audit reassuring.
- Users who want scale and prefer a service backed by a large, well-resourced privacy company.
- Users who only need broker removal and do not require dark web monitoring or FOIA filing.
Who Should Choose Sirveil
- Users who want dark web monitoring included as part of their base subscription.
- Users who need FOIA filing for government and institutional records.
- Mobile-first users who want a native mobile app (Android today, iOS coming soon) with push notifications.
- Users who prefer independent companies and want to avoid large privacy conglomerates.
- Users who value AI-native technology and want a service designed to adapt to the evolving broker landscape.
- Users who prioritize honest positioning over large claimed numbers.
Verdict
Incogni and Sirveil each have clear, defensible strengths. Incogni has a Deloitte audit, covers 420+ brokers explicitly, benefits from Nord Security's resources and scale, and is exceptionally cheap when bundled with a Surfshark VPN. These are real advantages that make Incogni an excellent choice for straightforward data broker removal.
Sirveil costs less as a standalone service and offers a broader feature set. Dark web monitoring, FOIA filing, and a native mobile app add capabilities that Incogni does not match. Its AI-native architecture represents a different philosophy: adapt dynamically rather than scale a static list.
If your priority is audited data broker removal bundled with a VPN, Incogni is hard to beat. If you want a more comprehensive privacy tool that includes dark web monitoring, FOIA capabilities, and a mobile-first experience — at a lower standalone price — Sirveil delivers.
Both services are honest about what they do. Neither can guarantee that every trace of your data will be removed from every corner of the internet. The right choice depends on which capabilities matter most to you and how much you are willing to spend.